Fishing requires more than just your rod and reel, and most fishing enthusiasts know that an organized tackle box makes their fishing experience less stressful, safer, easier, and more productive.  A good tackle box is a go-to hub for all things fishing, and can ideally reduce the clutter of your fishing trip, as well as your vehicle and garage or storage area.

In short, the best tackle box gives you exactly what you need, with easy access, right when you need it.

The term tackle box is used to describe everything from a small flat box with a snap down lid to a huge storage container divided into drawers, sections, and compartments. There are even tackle boxes out there that are not boxes at all, but rather soft-sides cases and backpacks. The tackle box that will be perfect for you will depend on the type of fishing you are going to be doing, and the amount of accessories and tackle you want to carry with you. Most avid anglers have several tackle boxes, in various sizes, so they are prepared for any fishing adventure they choose to go on.

It is very possible to get by with just one good tackle box, though, as long as it is a good match for the type of fishing you plan to do.

Best Large Tackle Box

A large tackle box is a staple of most fishing enthusiasts.  It is the mothership for all of your tackle, gear, and fishing supplies, kind of like a tool chest in a workshop.  Look for maximum storage space, a configuration that allows you to easy find things amid a sea of lures, and a strong build. If you are really organized, look for something that allows you to take a piece of it with you on smaller excursions, kind of like a satellite exploring away from the mothership.

Plano Guide Series 7771

plano best tackle box
Plano 7771

The Plano name is synonymous with tackle boxes, and has been since 1952 when they molded the first plastic tackle box.  The 7771 Guide Series is 21 x 12 x 12, giving you plenty of space for lots of lures and tackle. We like that it has 3 stows, which become part of the box when inserted, but can be grabbed quickly if you just want to bring a few jigs with you on a smaller outing.

This tackle box has plastic latches that close firmly. That feature makes this box an excellent choice for any angler, even saltwater fishermen. For ocean fishermen, the plastic latches will not corrode from exposure to the salt air. We have never had the box open unintentionally while in using, telling us that the latches are molded with quality.

One of the best features of the Plano Guide Series 7771 is the fact that it is customizable. You can order different boxes and drawers so you get to customize this unit to suit your individual needs.  This is a big plus if the type of fishing you do requires a stock of oddly-shaped supplies.

Plano offers a limited lifetime warranty on this tackle box.

SpiderWire Wolf Tackle Bag

best tackle bag soft
Spiderwire Wolf with plastic stows inside.

The concept of a tackle bag is something that people either love or hate. More and more fishing enthusiasts are moving to a soft-sided bag, and quickly adopting it as their primary tackle box.

We like bags – and the Spiderwire in particular – because it holds way more than tackle — you can use the various pouches for your other gear, plastic worms, a raincoat, sunglasses, lunch, whatever. This tackle bag has an extremely durable base. The base makes it last a lot longer but one of the biggest selling points to this bag is the sheer number of storage compartments/pockets that it has.

The traditional tackle goes into a series of plastic stows — either 4 or 5 — that insert into the large middle compartment. They can be places vertically or horizontally. We think putting them in vertically so you can see what is in each is the way to go.

With the SpiderWire Wolf Bag you will have both big and small pocket to hold every accessory you ever dreamed of carrying with you. It also has tool holders for your pliers and tools that are hard to fit into trays and pockets. For people who want their tackle box to be a little easier to transport and handle, the bag concept is a real winner. And of the bags, we like this Wolf model.

Best Smaller Tackle Box

A smaller tackle box is kind of like your satellite box when you don’t want to lug a huge box around.  For more occasional fishermen, it may be the only tackle box you need, assuming your fishing tends to be for inland lake or stream fish, and you aren’t doing anything like downrigging.

A smaller tackle box is also great for people who just want to take a kid fishing on occasion. You don’t need anything extravagant is your goal is simply to catch some panfish from the shoreline — you just need to be able to carry some basic hooks, jigs, and tackle.

Look for clever storage design, durability, and good portability.

Flambeau Outdoor Classic 3-tray Tackle Box

Flambeau is a trusted name in fishing gear, and storage equipment is their strong point. At 16 x 9 x 8, it has a much smaller profile than the boxes listed in the above section. It has a cantilever tray that extends to provide access to the multiple compartments.

Flambeau 3-Tray

This box has a drawtite latch that will keep the lid securely closed — we like the simple design and the ability to hear a secure “snap” to know this is locked shut. It has a groove design positioned between the lid and the base that allows the lid to sit in the groove and makes the box more water resistant.

There is a storage compartment on top of the lid of the box where you can store you most frequently used items.  With 32 tray compartments, there is plenty of space to put the gear for a typical day or two out, when you don’t want to carry a  huge box with you.

Plano Ready-Set-Fish 3 – Tray Tackle Box

The Plano Ready-Set-Fish  offers between 22-34 storage compartments. It comes in a 2 and 3 tray design. The 3-tray design measures 16 x 9 x 8.

The latch is a single brass bailed latch and it closes securely. Our experience on boxes of this size is that the latch is usually the first thing to go, so don’t skimp on it. The Planos are known for making a quality latch that will operate will thousands of times.

Beneath the trays is an ample storage compartment to hold larger items like extra line, needle nose pliers, and more. A nice feature of the Ready-Set-Fish is that many models are sold with a starter set of tackle already inside. Be sure that the source you are buying from carries the stocked box if this is what you want. Some of these models do not come stocked.

Best Backpacking Tackle Box

A backpacking tackle box, used for everything from paddling excursions to backpacking trips, is important if you plan to be in the backcountry.  Look for durability, and the ability to fit lots of gear into a small package.  An ideal setup might be to get a small pack that could fit inside your main large tackle box when not in use. If you are using the tackle box for fishing via canoe or kayak, you will want one that is highly waterproof, since there is always the chance of capsizing or getting soaked during a hard paddle. Our experience is that it is very hard to keep the floor of a canoe or kayak dry.

Wild River Multi Tackle Large Backpack

best backpacking tackle box
Wild River Multi Backpack

This is not a huge tackle backpack like the Wild River Tackle Tek Nomad. But it does have ample storage compartments, and can hold as many as six compartment trays in just the lower compartment of the bag. It does not come with the trays, giving you the opportunity to outfit it to the exact configuration you want.

This soft sided bag has adjustable padded straps that make carrying heavy loads more comfortable. It also has self retracting tool lanyards, a protective rain cover and an LED light system to help you in low light situations.

This bag can be used as a multi-purpose backpack that can carry tackle, water, food, and other supplies. We highly recommend it.

Flambeau Adjustable Compartment Box

This is a good, small box that can be tucked in to a canoe pack or backpack, and provides several small compartments on one level for your lures.  This small box has two removable dividers so it can be made to have 4 or 6 compartments. It is very light and made from polypropylene. It is translucent, so you can see directly in to each compartment without opening it, and has a positive locking latch and a detachable lid.

This is a very light box and the translucency is a nice feature. The plastic is strong and can hold up to some pressure inside your pack. If you prefer to not have another piece of gear to worry about on your canoe portage, and prefer to have everything stowed in your large packs, this might be the winner.

Best Ice Fishing Tackle Box

Ice fishing calls for another type of box in many cases.  We often find that we don’t need as much gear for ice fishing — you can remove the bottom bouncers, casting lures, and other noise. This lets you lighten your load a bit on the ice. Due to the potential extreme cold, look for strong materials that won’t crack in the frigid temps.  Ice fishing often involves more walking, so portability is a key as well.

Clam Ice Armor Jig Box

clam jig box best ice fishing
Clam Jig Box

Clam is a trusted name in ice fishing.  You will save time and frustration when you carry one of these boxes along on your trip, as long as you plan well and have everything you need in the small pack. This is a double sided box with clear covers so you can quickly identify what jigs are in the side you are viewing.  It is called a jig box by Clam, but has enough compartments to carry supplies for an afternoon outing on the ice. It comes in three sizes, with the smallest measuring 5 x 3 x 1, and the largest measuring 6 x 4 x 2.

Not large enough to take care of a serious fisherman who wants to fish for lots of different things, it is ideal for someone who knows what they are going to fish for, and won’t be out too long.  We even hear of fly fishermen using them because of the convenient size.

It can hold 250 jigs so you will never be without the jig you need when you need it. It is made of waterproof materials so your contents will stay dry.

An interesting combo would be to use this Ice Armor box for shorter situations focused on a single type of fish, and then throw it into a larger soft-sided Wolf Tackle Bag for those longer days when you are hosting a few people or just want the versatility to go after anything.

Our Criteria for Tackle Boxes

Saying something is the “best” really means that the item is the “best” according to the criteria you use when judging the product. When it come to tackle boxes we have the following list of features we believe a great tackle box is required to have.

Durability. Self explanatory. You need your tackle box to hold up to wear and tear, or else the investment will be a poor one. The old saying of garbage-in, garbage-out is true. Buy a quality box, spend a little more, and you will end up actually spending less over time.  If you are going with a soft-sided bag or pack, be sure that the material is tough and waterproof, and that the zippers look like they are built with some heft and quality.

High quality materials.  The quality of the materials used will determine how happy you are with the tackle box you choose. When looking at hard sided boxes we look for plastic that is not too thin, because the thinner plastic breaks easily. When comparing soft side bags we look for quality stitching, especially on the seam that attaches the carry strap to the bag.

Storage space.  Probably the first thing that many people look for.  Plenty of storage is a necessity for any tackle box. You want maximum storage compartments for the size of box you have chosen, and you want a variety in the configuration of the storage.  The space needed for a steel leader is different than that needed for a small fly.

Features, Bells, and Whistles.  We never recommend buying your tackle box based on bells and whistles, but there are a few that are nice-to-have. Having some built-in ruler, even if it is imprinted on a stow, is nice in places where length slot limits exist. We like a built-in, waterproof holder for your fishing license. And some boxes come fully-stocked with tackle – which is not good if you have a preference on your lures, but is good if you are just getting started.

Water Resistance. Water resistant materials help to protect your tackle box contents. We know that it is virtually impossible to find a tackle box that is 100% waterproof or watersealed, but when you choose a soft sided bag you want to get one made of water resistant materials. As for molded plastic boxes, just be sure that any metal and hardware is rust-proof, like on the hinges or latches.

Worm proof tray technology. For live bait and treated worm fishermen, this keeps your lures from becoming too soft and sticking together. It is overkill if you are only an artificial lure fishing enthusiast, but a great feature if you regularly use live bait.

Latches that close firmly. Nothing is worse than having your box pop open unexpectedly, and having to spend the next 20 minutes picking up lures, flies, and hooks. Our experience is that latches are the first thing to go, so start with the latch and be sure it works flawlessly. Settle for nothing less. We actually like boxes that have multiple latches, but you typically only get that at the larger sizes.

Tackle Box or Tackle Bag?

tackle bag vs. box
Bag (left) and box (right)

Soft-sided tackle bags have become more and more popular lately.  The old-fashioned, hard-sided tackle box is still the most popular, but we know lots of avid fishermen who switched to a soft-sided bag and have not gone back.  It really comes down to personal preference, but we suggest you give both a look.

In our opinion, a hard tackle box keeps lures and gear more neatly organized, and tends to be more waterproof in the boat or a rand storm.  We also like that a tackle box is more intuitive if multiple people will be using it.  You can see things more clearly.  If you are bringing the tackle for a group of 2-3 people, a box might be the easiest to use.  We also like that a tackle box stores easily and flatly in a storage room or garage, and can be neatly placed on a shelf with easy access just like a tool box.

The tackle bag comes in handy when the name of the came is portability.  They are generally easier to lug around, so if you are walking-in to a fishing spot that requires a mile hike first, you just might find that a tackle bag is the best choice.  Tackle boxes are just kind of bulky, unless you get a tiny one that can fit inside your other gear.  We also find that many solo fishing enthusiasts prefer the tackle bag, because it often allows them to go to the boat or fishing spot in one trip, rather than having to lug multiple containers and boxes around.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *